Updated on September 26, 2023

30 Of Dave Portnoy’s Favorite Pizza Joints Closest To Delaware

Dave Portnoy, founder of Barstool Sports and famed pizza reviewer, has been to plenty of pizza shops in our area over the last few years.

His online pizza reviews called ‘One Bite Pizza Reviews‘ have added to his Barstool fame.  He rates pizzas from around the US on a scale of one to 10.  One bite, everyone knows the rules.

Part of his criteria is how much grease it has or “the flop”, and he’s always looking for a well-done “undercarriage.” His favorite style is Neapolitan with no toppings, only cheese. His ratings are brutally honest and don’t always make for the happiest local owners.  If you’re in the 7 range, consider yourself to have a good pie.

While Portnoy has yet to visit any local spots here in Delaware, he has been to quite a few locations pretty close by, in Philadelphia and neighboring suburbs.   Each of his reviews is recorded by his pal Frankie or another Barstool friend, and posted on his many social media pages.

We’ve found 30 of the locations closest to Wilmington and listed them below, along with Dave’s rating and video review.

We love this guy.  We’ve got to get him to Delaware.   To do that, we need pizza reviews on Portnoy’s app, One Bite.

Check out the list of 23 Of Dave Portnoy’s Favorite Pizza Joints Closest To Delaware

• Angelo's Pizzeria - Philadelphia

  Dave Portnoy’s Rating – 9.1

• Circles + Squares - Philadelphia

  Dave Portnoy’s Rating – 8.2

   

• Pizzata Pizzeria - Philadelphia

  Dave Portnoy’s Rating – 8.1

• Pizza Jawn - Philadelphia

  Dave Portnoy’s Rating – 8.1

   

• Cesare's Ristorante - Bristol

  Dave Portnoy’s Rating – 8.1

   

• Wood Street Pizza - Philadelphia

  Dave Portnoy’s Rating – 8.1

• Tacconelli's Pizzeria -Philadelphia

  Dave Portnoy’s Rating – 8.1

• Angelino's Restaurant - Fairmount-Philadelphia

  Dave Portnoy’s Rating – 7.9

   

• Pizza Shackamaxon - Philadelphia

  Dave Portnoy’s Rating – 7.9

• Vince's Pizzeria - Philadelphia

  Dave Portnoy’s Rating – 7.9

• Pica's Restaurant of Upper Darby - Upper Darby

  Dave Portnoy’s Rating – 7.8

• Gaetano's Pizzeria - Clifton Heights

  Dave Portnoy’s Rating – 7.8

• Charlie's Pizzeria - Philadelphia

  Dave Portnoy’s Rating – 7.6

• Santucci's Original Square Pizza - Philadelphia

  Dave Portnoy’s Rating – 7.5

• Pizzeria Beddia - Philadelphia

  Dave Portnoy’s Rating – 7.4

• Randazzo's Pizzeria - Philadelphia

  Dave Portnoy’s Rating – 7.4

• Giovani's Bar & Grill - Philadelphia

  Dave Portnoy’s Rating – 7.4

• Franzone's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Manayunk

  Dave Portnoy’s Rating – 7.4

• Montesini Pizza - Philadelphia

  Dave Portnoy’s Rating – 7.4

• Vino's Pizza - Lafayette Hill

  Dave Portnoy’s Rating – 7.4

• Pietro's Coal Oven Pizza - Philadelphia

  Dave Portnoy’s Rating – 7.4

• Cafe Carmela - Philadelphia

  Dave Portnoy’s Rating – 7.3

• Sam's Boardwalk Style Pizza & Bottle Shop - Havertown

  Dave Portnoy’s Rating – 7.3

• Tony's Famous Tomato Pie - Philadelphia

  Dave Portnoy’s Rating – 7.3

• Tony & Joe's - Conshohocken

  Dave Portnoy’s Rating – 7.3

• Pizzeria Stella - Philadelphia

  Dave Portnoy’s Rating – 7.1

• Maxi's Pizza, Subs & Bar - Philadelphia

  Dave Portnoy’s Rating – 7.1

• Campus Corner - Villanova

  Dave Portnoy’s Rating – 6.9

• Pizza West Chester - West Chester

  Dave Portnoy’s Rating – 8.4

• West Chester Pizza Cafe - West Chester

  Dave Portnoy’s Rating – 8.1

Sign me up for the WJBR email newsletter!

You love WJBR, so join the Insiders Club! Be the first to know about local events, concerts and contests, and get the latest updates with your favorite artists, and more delivered right to your inbox.

First Name *

Last Name

Email *

Subscribe

By clicking "Subscribe" I agree to the website's terms of Service and Privacy Policy. I understand I can unsubscribe at any time.